How to Evaluate Whether Property Management Fees Are Worth It

Renting out a property can be lucrative, but it also brings a long list of responsibilities such as tenant screening, maintenance coordination, rent collection, and adherence to local laws.

Most landlords rely on property management services, which are professionals at managing these tasks efficiently. But one question that always arises is: Do property management fees actually pay off?

The response will vary according to how you assess the expenses and values that professional management creates. This guide will show you how to determine if paying property management fees makes sense for your particular situation - and help make sure you’re getting a good return on investment.

1. Understanding Typical Property Management Fees

Before you can even decide if the cost is worth it, you have to know what it is that you are actually paying for.

The vast majority of property management firms charge a monthly management fee, usually in the 8% to 12% range of collected rent. If your property rents for $2,000 a month and the management company takes 10%, then the monthly fee will be $200.

Other than base fees, you will also be confronted with:

• Leasing or tenant placement fees: Typically one month’s rent, or a percentage of it.

• Coordination of Maintenance fees: A nominal percentage (say 5–10%) “cut” on repairs.

• Lease renewal fees: A flat fee or lump-sum portion of a month’s rent when a tenant renews.

• Eviction or legal fees: Charged if eviction is necessary.

• Setup fees: These are fees for the one-time onboarding of your property into their system.

Although those may sound like hefty sums, the pertinent issue is not only how much you are paying, but what you are getting for your money.

2. What You Gain from a Property Management Company

A good property management firm does far more than take rent. Most of the time, their services drive efficiencies, curtail vacancy and provide a cost-effective solution. Here’s how they can justify their fees:

a. Lower Vacancy Rates

Our professional property managers are experts at marketing your home. They rely on professional photography, listing across platforms and local market indicators to attract qualified tenants quickly, minimizing downtime between leases.

b. Better Tenant Screening

A vigorous screening process will single out good tenants who pay rent on time and treat your property well. This minimizes the risk of unpaid debts, late payment delays or expensive evictions.

c. Professional Maintenance Management

Property managers tend to have preferred vendors (and the associated discounted rates and speedier service). Preventive maintenance can also save thousands in the long run by catching problems early.

d. Legal and Compliance Expertise

Landlord-tenant codes can get convoluted, particularly in big cities like Chicago or Los Angeles. Property managers keep you in line with safety codes, fair housing laws and local ordinances reducing the risk of legal issues or fines.

3. Calculating Your Return on Investment (ROI)

To determine if the fees are worth it, calculate the Return on Investment (ROI) you’re receiving from professional management. Here’s a simple formula:

ROI = (Net Benefit of Intervention – Management Costs) ÷ Management Costs × 100

For instance, if your property management company costs you $3,000 a year but also helps you make or save $6,000 (in reduced vacancy, better rent collection and fewer repair costs), your return on investment is 100%. That’s a sure sign the service is paying off.

And you can compare metrics before and after, like:

• Vacancy rate

• Maintenance costs

• Tenant turnover

• Rent collection rate

• Average rent per unit

If your income goes up and expenses go down, you come out ahead even with the fees a management company charges.

4. When Property Management Fees Might Not Be Worth It

There are scenarios when hiring a property manager might not make financial sense. 

For example:

• You own just one modest little place and can easily care for it yourself.

• You have a cash flow problem now, and those 1% management fees are going to eat deeply into profits.

• You have experience with tenant relations and maintenance, and you have the time to manage it.

For such cases, self-care may be a less expensive option. But if you build it out in your portfolio or see your schedule get busier, hiring a property manager might offer a better return on time.

Final Thoughts

Property management fees are a given when you enlist professional help, but it’s not just a cost, it’s an investment in efficiency, protection and peace of mind.

To determine if they’re worth it, you must look beyond the percentage and understand what value you are really getting.

If your investment is performing well, the tenants are happy, and you have a good cash flow without doing too much of the work yourself, then fees are what they should be: making your life easier and increasing the profit from your investment.

---

Our writers like to find the latest trends for the home and garden. We launched the award-winning Seasons in Colour in 2015 and the luxury property and interior decor blog www.alltheprettyhomes.com in 2024 to cover all your interior design, travel and lifestyle inspiration needs. Download our free bathroom renovation guide here.